how to compare rsus vs options in job offers

When you receive a tech job offer, the compensation package often includes equity—either Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) or stock options. Deciding which is more valuable can feel like solving a math puzzle while also weighing risk, tax implications, and your career timeline. This guide walks you through the fundamentals, provides a step‑by‑step comparison checklist, and answers the most common questions so you can negotiate with confidence.

1. What Are RSUs?

Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are promises to deliver a certain number of company shares after a vesting schedule is met. Unlike options, you do not need to purchase the shares; they are granted outright once they vest. The value of an RSU is directly tied to the current market price of the stock at the time of vesting, making it a relatively straightforward component of compensation.

Key characteristics

• No purchase price – you receive the shares for free.
• Taxed as ordinary income when they vest (based on fair market value).
• Vesting schedules typically 3‑4 years with a one‑year cliff.

Example

A company offers you 5,000 RSUs that vest over four years (25 % each year). If the stock trades at $50 when the first tranche vests, you receive $2,500 of taxable income that year.

2. What Are Stock Options?

Stock options give you the right, but not the obligation, to buy a set number of shares at a predetermined exercise price (also called strike price). The potential upside comes from the difference between the market price at exercise and the strike price.

Key characteristics

• You must pay the strike price to exercise the option.
• Tax treatment varies (ordinary income, AMT, or capital gains) depending on whether they are Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) or Non‑Qualified Stock Options (NSOs).
• Vesting schedules are similar to RSUs, but you only benefit if the market price exceeds the strike price.

Example

You receive 5,000 options with a $30 strike price, vesting over four years. If the stock is $70 when you exercise the first 25 % tranche, your pre‑tax gain is ($70‑$30) × 1,250 = $50,000.

3. Core Differences at a Glance

Mini‑conclusion: When you compare RSUs vs options in job offers, focus on cash outlay, tax impact, and the probability that the stock will appreciate beyond the strike price.

4. How to Value RSUs

1. Determine the number of RSUs offered.
2. Find the current market price of the company’s stock (or the most recent private‑company valuation if it’s a startup).
3. Calculate the gross value: RSU count × current price.
4. Adjust for vesting: Multiply by the percentage that will vest each year.
5. Estimate taxes: Assume a marginal tax rate (e.g., 30 %). Tax = gross value × rate.
6. Net after‑tax value = gross value − tax.

Quick Calculator (example)

• 5,000 RSUs
• Current price $45
• 25 % vest each year
• Tax rate 30 %

Year 1 gross = 5,000 × 0.25 × $45 = $56,250 Year 1 tax = $56,250 × 0.30 = $16,875 Year 1 net = $39,375

Repeat for each year; sum to get total net RSU value.

5. How to Value Stock Options

Valuing options is more complex because you must forecast future stock price. A common method is the Black‑Scholes model, but a simpler approach for most candidates is a scenario analysis:

1. Identify the strike price and number of options.
2. Project three stock price scenarios for the vesting horizon (conservative, base, aggressive).
3. Calculate potential gain for each scenario: (Projected price − strike) × options vested.
4. Apply probability weights (e.g., 20 % conservative, 50 % base, 30 % aggressive).
5. Estimate tax impact based on your expected filing status (use 30 % as a rough average).
6. Compute expected after‑tax gain.

Example Scenario

• 5,000 options, $30 strike
• Vesting 25 % per year
• Projected price after 1 year: $40 (conservative), $55 (base), $80 (aggressive)

Conservative gain = (40‑30) × 1,250 = $12,500 Base gain = (55‑30) × 1,250 = $31,250 Aggressive gain = (80‑30) × 1,250 = $62,500

Weighted expected gain = 0.2 × 12.5k + 0.5 × 31.25k + 0.3 × 62.5k ≈ $33,125

Tax (30 %) ≈ $9,938 → Net expected value ≈ $23,187 for the first year.

Repeat for subsequent years and sum.

6. Step‑by‑Step Comparison Checklist

Use this checklist when you open a new offer letter.

Mini‑conclusion: This checklist turns the abstract comparison of RSUs vs options into a concrete, repeatable process.

7. Real‑World Scenarios

Scenario A – Established Public Company

• Offer: 4,000 RSUs, 4‑year vesting, current price $120.
• No stock options.

Result: Net after‑tax RSU value ≈ $134,400 (assuming 30 % tax). Low risk, high certainty.

Scenario B – Fast‑Growing Startup

• Offer: 6,000 options, $10 strike, 4‑year vesting.
• Current private valuation implies $15 per share.

Result: Using a base‑case projection of $30 per share in 2 years, net expected value ≈ $63,000 after tax. Higher upside but dependent on successful exit.

Scenario C – Mixed Package

• 2,000 RSUs + 3,000 options (strike $25), current price $40.

Result: RSU net ≈ $42,000; options weighted net ≈ $18,000. Mixed approach reduces risk while preserving upside.

These examples illustrate how the mix of RSUs and options can be tailored to your risk tolerance and career horizon.

8. Do’s and Don’ts

Do

• Model multiple price scenarios for options.
• Consider your tax bracket now and at the time of sale.
• Check the company’s liquidity plan (IPO, acquisition, secondary market).
• Leverage Resumly’s career tools—the salary guide helps benchmark base pay, while the career guide offers negotiation tips.

Don’t

• Assume the current price will stay the same for the entire vesting period.
• Ignore the exercise window after vesting (many companies require you to exercise within 90 days).
• Overlook alternative minimum tax (AMT) if you have ISOs.
• Negotiate equity in isolation; always look at the total compensation package.

9. Tools to Simplify the Process

Resumly offers several free tools that can speed up your equity analysis and overall job‑search workflow:

• AI Career Clock – visualizes how long it will take to hit compensation milestones.
• ATS Resume Checker – ensures your resume passes automated screens, increasing interview chances.
• Job‑Search Keywords – helps you find roles that match your compensation goals.

Integrating these tools with your equity calculations gives you a holistic view of both salary and equity.

10. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Are RSUs always better than options? A: Not necessarily. RSUs provide certainty, while options can deliver higher upside if the company’s stock skyrockets. Your choice depends on risk tolerance and confidence in the company’s growth.

Q2: How does a “one‑year cliff” affect my equity? A: You receive no equity if you leave before the first anniversary. After the cliff, a chunk (often 25 %) vests, then the rest vests monthly or quarterly.

Q3: What is the tax difference between ISOs and NSOs? A: ISOs may qualify for favorable long‑term capital gains treatment but can trigger AMT. NSOs are taxed as ordinary income at exercise.

Q4: Can I sell RSUs immediately after they vest? A: Usually yes, unless the company imposes a lock‑up period (common before an IPO). Check the plan documents.

Q5: What happens to unvested equity if the company is acquired? A: Acquisition terms vary—unvested RSUs may accelerate, while options might be assumed, cash‑settled, or cancelled. Review the change‑of‑control clause.

Q6: Should I negotiate for more RSUs or a higher salary? A: If you prefer cash certainty, ask for a higher base salary. If you believe in the company’s future, request additional RSUs or a lower strike price on options.

Q7: How do I track my vesting schedule? A: Use an equity tracker spreadsheet or a dedicated app. Resumly’s application tracker can be repurposed to monitor vesting dates alongside job applications.

Q8: Is there a rule of thumb for the RSU‑to‑salary ratio? A: Many tech firms target 15‑25 % of total compensation in equity. Compare your offer against the salary guide for your role and region.

11. Final Thoughts – Making the Decision

When you sit down to compare RSUs vs options in job offers, start with the numbers: calculate net after‑tax values, model realistic stock price scenarios, and align vesting with your personal timeline. Then layer in qualitative factors—company stability, growth outlook, and your own risk appetite. By following the checklist, using the do/don’t list, and leveraging Resumly’s free career tools, you’ll turn a confusing equity package into a clear, negotiable component of your total compensation.

Ready to boost the rest of your job search? Explore Resumly’s AI resume builder and start landing offers that match both your salary and equity goals.