RESUME MISTAKES

Elevate Your Ministry Career with a Perfect Pastor Resume

Identify and correct the pitfalls that keep your resume from resonating with church leadership and ATS.

How This Page Helps
Help pastors craft a compelling, ATS‑friendly resume by highlighting frequent mistakes and providing clear, actionable fixes.
Spot the most common resume errors that keep you from getting called to a new congregation
Learn how to rewrite each section for maximum impact
Get ATS‑ready formatting tips specific to ministry roles
Use real‑world examples to see before‑and‑after transformations

Common Mistakes That Kill Your Chances

Each mistake includes why it hurts, how to fix it, and before/after examples

Vague Objective StatementMEDIUM
Why it hurts
  • Provides no insight into your ministry impact
  • ATS often skips generic objectives
  • Hiring leaders can’t gauge your fit quickly
How to fix
  • Replace the objective with a concise summary that highlights years of experience, congregation size, and measurable outcomes
  • Incorporate key ministry keywords early in the summary
❌ Before

Objective: To serve as a pastor.

✓ After

Summary: Dedicated pastor with 12 years of experience leading multi‑cultural congregations, growing weekly attendance by 35% and launching community outreach programs serving 500+ families.

ATS Tip
Lead with keywords like "pastor," "leadership," "congregational growth," and "community outreach" within the first 3 lines.
Detection Rules
Presence of an "Objective" heading
Lack of numbers or specific achievements
Resumly Tip
Swap the objective for a results‑driven summary that showcases impact.
Listing Duties Without ImpactHIGH
Why it hurts
  • Bullet points read like a job description, not a personal achievement
  • Hiring committees miss evidence of leadership
  • ATS scores lower when no quantifiable data is present
How to fix
  • Start each bullet with a strong action verb
  • Add measurable results (attendance growth, budget size, volunteer hours)
  • Show how you solved problems or introduced new programs
❌ Before

- Conducted weekly worship services. - Provided pastoral counseling. - Managed church finances.

✓ After

- Designed and delivered weekly worship services that increased attendance by 28% over 2 years. - Provided pastoral counseling to 120+ individuals, achieving a 95% satisfaction rating. - Oversaw a $250K annual budget, reducing expenses by 12% while expanding community programs.

ATS Tip
Include numbers (%, $) and action verbs such as "designed," "expanded," "reduced."
Detection Rules
Bullets begin with generic verbs like "responsible for"
No percentages, dollar amounts, or counts
Resumly Tip
Transform duty‑based bullets into achievement‑focused statements with metrics.
Overusing Religious JargonLOW
Why it hurts
  • Non‑ministry recruiters may not understand specialized terms
  • ATS may not recognize uncommon phrasing
  • Can appear exclusionary to broader faith‑based organizations
How to fix
  • Replace niche terms with universally understood language (e.g., "sermon" instead of "homily" if appropriate)
  • Keep spiritual language in the summary, but use clear descriptors in experience sections
❌ Before

- Delivered exegesis of the Pauline epistles during the liturgy. - Facilitated sacraments in accordance with ecclesiastical canon law.

✓ After

- Presented weekly sermons interpreting New Testament teachings, increasing engagement among young adults. - Administered baptisms, weddings, and funerals, ensuring compliance with denominational standards.

ATS Tip
Use plain language that still conveys spiritual leadership; ATS parses common words better.
Detection Rules
Presence of terms like "exegesis," "liturgical canon"
Lack of plain‑English equivalents
Resumly Tip
Swap dense theological terms for clear, impact‑focused language.
Missing or Inconsistent DatesMEDIUM
Why it hurts
  • ATS cannot sequence your career timeline
  • Hiring managers may question gaps or longevity
How to fix
  • Standardize all dates to "MMM YYYY" format (e.g., Jan 2018 – Dec 2022)
  • Ensure every role, education entry, and certification includes start and end dates
❌ Before

Senior Pastor St. Mark Church 2015 – Present Bachelor of Theology Faith Seminary 2009 – 2013

✓ After

Senior Pastor St. Mark Church Jan 2015 – Present Bachelor of Theology Faith Seminary Sep 2009 – Jun 2013

ATS Tip
Consistent date formatting improves parsing and chronological accuracy.
Detection Rules
Date lines missing month
Different date styles within same resume
Resumly Tip
Apply a uniform "MMM YYYY" format to all date entries.
Not Highlighting Certifications & OrdinationHIGH
Why it hurts
  • Credentials are critical for credibility in ministry roles
  • ATS often filters on required certifications (e.g., Ordained Minister)
  • Employers may overlook qualified candidates
How to fix
  • Create a dedicated "Certifications" section near the top of the resume
  • List ordination status, denominational affiliation, and any continuing education certificates
❌ Before

Education Faith Seminary – Bachelor of Theology, 2013

✓ After

Education Faith Seminary – Bachelor of Theology, 2013 Certifications - Ordained Minister, United Methodist Church, 2014 - Certified Chaplain, Association of Clinical Pastoral Education, 2016

ATS Tip
Use exact certification titles; match keywords from job postings.
Detection Rules
No separate certifications heading
Ordination mentioned only in narrative
Resumly Tip
Add a clear certifications section with official titles and dates.
Formatting Guidelines
File Types: PDF, DOCX
Sections: Contact Information, Professional Summary, Ministry Experience, Education, Certifications, Skills, Volunteer Work, References
Naming: FirstName_LastName_Pastor.pdf
Consistency
Length: 1–2 pages (max 2 pages for senior pastors)
Date Format: MMM YYYY (e.g., Jan 2020)
Location Format: City, State
Resume Quality Checklist
  • Use a professional header with phone, email, and LinkedIn
  • Write a results‑driven summary with ministry keywords
  • List experience in reverse chronological order with consistent dates
  • Quantify impact for every role
  • Include ordination and relevant certifications
  • Proofread for spelling, grammar, and theological accuracy
  • Save as PDF with the naming convention
ATS Alignment Guide
Common ATS Systems: Taleo, iCIMS, Workday, Greenhouse
Keyword Strategy: pastor, sermon, congregation, worship, pastoral care, community outreach, theological education, ordination, ministry leadership
Heading Format: Use standard headings like "Professional Experience," "Education," "Certifications," and "Skills"
Quick Fix Workshop
Paste your current pastor resume text into the box below
  • Convert passive verbs to active voice
  • Add measurable outcomes to each bullet
  • Standardize date format to MMM YYYY
  • Replace dense theological jargon with clear language
  • Insert a dedicated Certifications section
Download Checklist PDF
Ready to transform your pastoral resume? Get a free review now!
Download Resume Checklist

More Common Resume Mistakes

Check out Resumly's Free AI Tools