INTERVIEW

Ace Your Clergy Interview

Master the questions that matter to faith communities and leadership boards.

12 Questions
120 min Prep Time
5 Categories
STAR Method
What You'll Learn
Help clergy candidates confidently answer interview questions, showcase their pastoral competencies, and secure their next ministry role.
  • Understand the core competencies churches look for
  • Learn proven STAR‑based responses for common scenarios
  • Identify red flags interviewers watch for
  • Access a timed practice pack to simulate real interviews
Difficulty Mix
Easy: 40%
Medium: 35%
Hard: 25%
Prep Overview
Estimated Prep Time: 120 minutes
Formats: behavioral, situational, case study
Competency Map
Pastoral Care: 25%
Theology & Doctrine: 20%
Leadership & Administration: 20%
Community Engagement: 15%
Ethical Decision-Making: 10%
Communication Skills: 10%

Pastoral Care

Can you describe a time when you provided counseling to a congregant facing a personal crisis?
Situation

A long‑time member disclosed that her husband had been diagnosed with a terminal illness, leaving her overwhelmed and isolated.

Task

I needed to offer emotional support, help her process grief, and connect her with appropriate resources while respecting confidentiality.

Action

I scheduled a private meeting, practiced active listening, validated her feelings, prayed together, and referred her to a licensed grief counselor and our church’s support group. I followed up weekly.

Result

She reported feeling less isolated, engaged with the support group, and expressed gratitude for the holistic care, which strengthened her trust in the congregation.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How did you maintain confidentiality?
  • What resources did you consider beyond the church?
  • How did you involve other staff, if at all?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Demonstrates empathy and active listening
  • Shows knowledge of community resources
  • Maintains confidentiality
  • Provides measurable follow‑up
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Imposing personal beliefs without consent
  • Failing to refer to professional help when needed
  • Lack of follow‑up
Answer Outline
  • Describe the crisis and your role
  • Explain the counseling steps you took
  • Highlight resources you provided
  • Share the positive outcome
Tip
Focus on listening first; let the congregant lead the conversation before offering solutions.
Tell us about a situation where you helped a family navigate a conflict within the church community.
Situation

Two families in the congregation disagreed over the use of church facilities for a political rally, creating tension among members.

Task

Facilitate a resolution that honored the church’s mission while respecting differing viewpoints.

Action

I organized a mediated discussion, set ground rules for respectful dialogue, clarified the church’s policy on non‑partisan use of space, and encouraged both families to propose alternative solutions. I also consulted the church board for guidance.

Result

The families agreed to postpone the rally and instead host a neutral community forum, restoring harmony and reinforcing the church’s role as a unifying space.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What steps did you take to ensure neutrality?
  • How did you involve church leadership?
  • What would you do if the conflict escalated?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Neutral facilitation
  • Clear reference to church policy
  • Collaborative problem‑solving
  • Positive outcome
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Taking sides
  • Ignoring church policy
  • Avoiding the issue
Answer Outline
  • Set the context of the conflict
  • Explain the mediation process you led
  • Detail the policy reference and collaborative solution
  • Describe the restored relationship
Tip
Use neutral language and keep the focus on shared values and the church’s mission.
How have you supported congregants dealing with mental health challenges?
Situation

A young adult member disclosed symptoms of depression and anxiety, expressing hopelessness.

Task

Provide compassionate pastoral care while recognizing the need for professional mental‑health support.

Action

I listened without judgment, shared scriptural hope, and gently suggested a licensed therapist. I coordinated with the church’s mental‑health ministry to offer a support group and checked in weekly.

Result

The member began therapy, reported improved mood, and later volunteered to lead a youth mental‑health awareness session, strengthening the congregation’s support network.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How do you balance spiritual counsel with professional referrals?
  • What training have you received on mental health?
  • How do you ensure confidentiality?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Compassionate listening
  • Appropriate referral to professionals
  • Follow‑up care
  • Respect for confidentiality
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Attempting to replace professional therapy
  • Minimizing the issue
Answer Outline
  • Acknowledge the disclosure
  • Explain your pastoral response
  • Mention referral to professionals
  • Show the positive impact
Tip
Know local mental‑health resources and have a referral list ready.
Describe a time you helped a congregant discover and develop their spiritual gifts.
Situation

A new member expressed uncertainty about how to serve within the church after moving from another city.

Task

Identify her spiritual gifts and integrate her into meaningful ministry roles.

Action

I administered a spiritual gifts inventory, discussed the results in a one‑on‑one meeting, and paired her with a mentorship program in the worship team. I also invited her to lead a small‑group study aligned with her gifting in teaching.

Result

She became an active worship team member and later facilitated a weekly Bible study, increasing volunteer participation by 15%.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What tools do you use for gift assessment?
  • How do you track volunteer engagement?
  • How do you handle mismatched expectations?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Use of structured assessment
  • Personalized follow‑up
  • Integration into ministry
  • Positive impact on engagement
Red Flags to Avoid
  • One‑size‑fits‑all approach
  • Neglecting follow‑up
Answer Outline
  • Identify the need
  • Use assessment tools
  • Match gifts to ministry opportunities
  • Show measurable outcome
Tip
Combine formal assessments with personal conversations to get a holistic view.

Leadership & Administration

What experience do you have managing a church budget and financial stewardship?
Situation

When I became senior pastor at a mid‑size church, the annual budget was consistently overspent by 12% due to untracked program costs.

Task

Create a transparent budgeting process and bring expenses within the approved limits.

Action

I introduced a quarterly budgeting review, implemented a cloud‑based accounting system, trained ministry leaders on expense reporting, and established a stewardship committee to oversee donations and allocations.

Result

The church achieved a balanced budget within one fiscal year, increased donor confidence, and saw a 5% rise in weekly giving.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How did you involve the congregation in financial transparency?
  • What metrics did you track?
  • How did you handle resistance from ministry leaders?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Financial transparency
  • Stakeholder involvement
  • Effective use of tools
  • Measurable results
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Lack of transparency
  • Ignoring input from finance committee
Answer Outline
  • State the budgeting challenge
  • Describe the system you implemented
  • Explain training and oversight
  • Quantify the financial improvement
Tip
Regularly share simple financial summaries with the congregation to build trust.
Tell us about a time you led a major change initiative within your congregation.
Situation

Our church needed to transition from a traditional Sunday service to a hybrid model (in‑person and live‑stream) due to declining attendance and a growing online audience.

Task

Design and execute the transition while maintaining community cohesion.

Action

I formed a cross‑functional task force, conducted surveys to gauge preferences, secured a streaming platform, trained volunteers on tech, revised service flow, and communicated the vision through sermons, newsletters, and town‑hall meetings.

Result

Within six months, overall attendance rose 20%, online viewership grew to 300 weekly participants, and congregants reported feeling more connected regardless of location.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What resistance did you encounter and how did you address it?
  • How did you measure success?
  • What lessons would you apply to future changes?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Strategic planning
  • Stakeholder engagement
  • Effective communication
  • Quantifiable outcomes
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Imposing change without input
  • Neglecting technical support
Answer Outline
  • Identify the need for change
  • Form a task force and gather data
  • Implement technology and training
  • Communicate vision and measure outcomes
Tip
Pilot the new format with a small group before full rollout to troubleshoot issues.
How do you evaluate the effectiveness of your preaching and teaching ministries?
Situation

After a year of delivering weekly sermons, I wanted to ensure they were resonating and fostering spiritual growth.

Task

Create a feedback loop to assess impact and improve content.

Action

I introduced post‑service surveys, tracked small‑group attendance linked to sermon topics, held quarterly focus groups, and reviewed baptism and membership data for trends. I also sought peer reviews from fellow clergy.

Result

Survey scores improved from 3.5 to 4.6/5, small‑group participation increased by 12%, and we saw a 7% rise in new member inquiries.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What specific questions do you ask in surveys?
  • How do you balance quantitative data with spiritual discernment?
  • How often do you adjust sermon series based on feedback?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Use of multiple feedback sources
  • Data‑driven adjustments
  • Peer collaboration
  • Demonstrated growth
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Relying solely on attendance numbers
  • Ignoring qualitative feedback
Answer Outline
  • Explain the need for assessment
  • Detail feedback mechanisms
  • Show data analysis
  • Present improvements
Tip
Combine numeric data with personal testimonies for a fuller picture.
Describe your approach to developing and mentoring lay leaders.
Situation

Our church had a high turnover of volunteer leaders, affecting program continuity.

Task

Create a sustainable leadership development pipeline.

Action

I launched a 12‑month mentorship program pairing experienced elders with emerging volunteers, offered quarterly leadership workshops, and instituted clear role descriptions with competency checklists. I also recognized achievements publicly each quarter.

Result

Volunteer retention rose 30%, program quality improved, and several mentees advanced to senior ministry positions within two years.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How do you match mentors and mentees?
  • What competencies do you prioritize?
  • How do you evaluate program success?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Structured mentorship
  • Clear competency framework
  • Recognition mechanisms
  • Retention improvement
Red Flags to Avoid
  • One‑size‑all training
  • Lack of follow‑up
Answer Outline
  • Identify turnover issue
  • Outline mentorship structure
  • Provide training and recognition
  • Show retention metrics
Tip
Tailor mentorship goals to each individual’s gifts and career aspirations.

Theology & Doctrine

How do you ensure your sermons are theologically sound while remaining accessible to a diverse congregation?
Situation

Our congregation includes members from various denominational backgrounds, making theological nuance challenging.

Task

Deliver biblically accurate sermons that resonate across traditions.

Action

I conduct thorough exegesis using reputable commentaries, consult with a theological advisory board, and then translate key concepts into everyday language with relatable illustrations. I also invite questions after services to clarify misunderstandings.

Result

Feedback surveys indicated a 92% comprehension rate, and attendance at post‑service Q&A sessions increased by 40%.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What resources do you rely on for exegesis?
  • How do you handle doctrinal disagreements?
  • How do you balance depth with brevity?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Rigorous biblical scholarship
  • Clear communication
  • Openness to dialogue
  • Positive audience response
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Oversimplifying doctrine
  • Avoiding difficult topics
Answer Outline
  • Explain research process
  • Describe translation to lay language
  • Mention feedback mechanisms
  • Show comprehension metrics
Tip
Use analogies that respect cultural contexts while staying true to the text.
Can you give an example of how you addressed a controversial theological issue within your church?
Situation

A debate arose over the church’s stance on same‑sex marriage, causing division among members.

Task

Facilitate a respectful theological discussion and guide the congregation toward a unified, biblically informed position.

Action

I organized a series of teaching sessions presenting scriptural perspectives, invited guest theologians representing differing views, and held moderated small‑group discussions. I also referenced our denomination’s official statements and emphasized core Christian values of love and grace.

Result

While opinions remained varied, the process reduced hostility, and the congregation voted to adopt an official statement emphasizing pastoral care for all individuals, preserving unity and mission focus.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How did you manage emotional reactions?
  • What if the issue threatened membership numbers?
  • How do you ensure ongoing pastoral care?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Balanced theological presentation
  • Facilitation of respectful dialogue
  • Reference to authority
  • Maintaining unity
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Taking a unilateral stance without consultation
  • Suppressing dissent
Answer Outline
  • Set the context of controversy
  • Outline educational and dialogue steps
  • Reference denominational guidance
  • Present outcome
Tip
Ground discussions in Scripture and official doctrine, but prioritize compassion.
What methods do you use to stay current with theological scholarship and apply it to ministry?
Situation

Balancing pastoral duties with ongoing learning can be demanding.

Task

Create a sustainable personal development plan for theological growth.

Action

I allocate weekly reading time for academic journals, attend annual theological conferences, participate in an online clergy study group, and subscribe to a denominational newsletter. I then integrate insights into sermons, teaching series, and counseling sessions.

Result

My sermons have been noted for depth and relevance, and congregants frequently reference recent theological insights in their personal study groups.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How do you prioritize topics?
  • What resources are most valuable?
  • How do you share learning with staff?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Consistent study habits
  • Engagement with scholarly peers
  • Practical application
  • Positive feedback
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Neglecting ongoing education
  • Relying solely on personal opinion
Answer Outline
  • Schedule dedicated study time
  • Engage with scholarly communities
  • Apply learning to preaching and counseling
  • Show impact
Tip
Blend academic study with practical ministry to keep learning grounded.
Explain how you integrate biblical ethics into decision‑making for church operations.
Situation

A proposal emerged to rent church facilities to a for‑profit event that conflicted with our mission values.

Task

Assess the proposal through a biblical ethical lens and decide appropriately.

Action

I convened a leadership council, examined relevant Scripture on stewardship and witness, consulted our denominational ethics guidelines, and gathered congregational input via a survey. We concluded the event conflicted with our mission and declined the rental, offering alternative community‑focused uses for the space.

Result

The decision reinforced our integrity, and the community responded positively, leading to increased volunteer interest for future outreach programs.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What biblical principles guided you?
  • How do you balance financial needs with ethics?
  • How do you communicate such decisions to stakeholders?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Scriptural grounding
  • Transparent process
  • Stakeholder involvement
  • Alignment with mission
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Prioritizing profit over principle
  • Lack of consultation
Answer Outline
  • Present ethical dilemma
  • Describe biblical and policy framework used
  • Outline decision process
  • Show outcome and community response
Tip
Document the ethical reasoning to maintain accountability and clarity.
ATS Tips
  • pastoral counseling
  • sermon preparation
  • community outreach
  • leadership
  • theology
  • conflict resolution
  • budget management
  • spiritual gifts
Get a clergy resume template
Practice Pack
Timed Rounds: 30 minutes
Mix: easy, medium, hard

Ready to land your next ministry role?

Get Started Now

More Interview Guides

Check out Resumly's Free AI Tools