INTERVIEW

Master Your Paralegal Interview

Practice proven questions, refine your answers, and land the role you deserve.

9 Questions
120 min Prep Time
5 Categories
STAR Method
What You'll Learn
To equip aspiring and current paralegals with targeted interview questions, expert model answers, and actionable preparation strategies.
  • Boost confidence with real‑world question examples
  • Learn STAR‑structured model answers
  • Identify key competencies interviewers seek
  • Spot red flags and avoid common pitfalls
  • Get tips to tailor answers to any law firm
Difficulty Mix
Easy: 40%
Medium: 40%
Hard: 20%
Prep Overview
Estimated Prep Time: 120 minutes
Formats: behavioral, legal knowledge, situational
Competency Map
Legal Research: 20%
Document Management: 15%
Client Communication: 20%
Ethical Judgment: 25%
Time Management: 20%

Behavioral

Describe a time when you had to manage competing deadlines.
Situation

At my previous firm, two senior attorneys required draft pleadings for separate cases due the same Friday.

Task

I needed to prioritize, allocate resources, and ensure both filings were accurate and on time.

Action

I created a detailed schedule, delegated research tasks to junior staff, and set interim check‑ins. I also communicated progress updates to both attorneys daily.

Result

Both pleadings were submitted ahead of deadline, received commendations for quality, and the attorneys praised my organizational skills.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How did you decide which task to prioritize first?
  • What tools did you use to track progress?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Clarity of the situation
  • Demonstrated prioritization and delegation
  • Effective communication
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Vague timeline, no specific actions
Answer Outline
  • Explain the context and competing deadlines
  • State your responsibility to meet both
  • Detail the planning, delegation, and communication steps
  • Highlight the successful on‑time delivery and positive feedback
Tip
Quantify the number of deadlines and mention any tools (e.g., Outlook, Trello) you used.
Tell me about a situation where you discovered an error in a legal document.
Situation

While reviewing a contract for a real‑estate closing, I noticed a typo in the property address that could invalidate the deed.

Task

I had to correct the error before the signing deadline without compromising the client’s trust.

Action

I flagged the issue to the supervising attorney, cross‑checked the original deed, and prepared an amendment with the correct address. I then informed the client and the title company of the correction.

Result

The amendment was filed promptly, the closing proceeded on schedule, and the client appreciated the diligence, reinforcing the firm’s reputation for accuracy.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What steps do you take to prevent similar errors?
  • How did you communicate the mistake to the client?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Attention to detail
  • Ethical handling of errors
  • Clear communication
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Blaming others, no corrective action
Answer Outline
  • Identify the document and error
  • Explain your responsibility to correct it
  • Describe the steps taken to verify and amend
  • Conclude with the successful outcome
Tip
Emphasize the proactive approach and client communication.
How do you handle confidential information in a law office?
Situation

Our firm handles sensitive client files, including medical records and financial statements.

Task

Ensure all confidential data remains secure and is shared only with authorized personnel.

Action

I follow the firm’s confidentiality policy: lock physical files, encrypt digital documents, use secure file‑sharing platforms, and verify recipient permissions before transmission. I also conduct briefings with staff on privacy protocols.

Result

No breaches have occurred during my tenure, and audits consistently rate our department’s data security as exemplary.

Follow‑up Questions
  • Can you give an example of a confidentiality breach you prevented?
  • What software do you use for secure document sharing?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Understanding of confidentiality rules
  • Specific security measures
Red Flags to Avoid
  • General statements without concrete steps
Answer Outline
  • State the importance of confidentiality
  • Outline physical and digital safeguards
  • Mention verification and staff training
  • Result: zero breaches
Tip
Reference relevant regulations (e.g., HIPAA, GDPR) if applicable.

Legal Knowledge

What are the key differences between a summons and a subpoena?
Situation

During case intake, clients often ask about procedural documents.

Task

Explain the distinct purposes and requirements of summonses versus subpoenas.

Action

I clarified that a summons notifies a defendant of a lawsuit and compels a response, while a subpoena commands a person to appear in court or produce evidence. I highlighted that summonses are filed by the plaintiff, whereas subpoenas can be issued by the court or an attorney and may require a court order.

Result

Clients understood the procedural steps, reducing confusion and ensuring timely compliance.

Follow‑up Questions
  • When might a subpoena be challenged?
  • What are the service requirements for a summons?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Accurate definitions
  • Clear contrast
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Mixing up definitions
Answer Outline
  • Define summons and its purpose
  • Define subpoena and its purpose
  • Contrast filing authority and required actions
Tip
Mention service deadlines for summonses (e.g., 30 days) to show depth.
Explain the process of filing a civil lawsuit from intake to service of process.
Situation

At my previous firm, I was responsible for managing the early stages of civil litigation.

Task

Guide the team through intake, complaint drafting, filing, and serving the defendant.

Action

I gathered client facts, performed conflict checks, and drafted the complaint. After attorney review, I filed the complaint electronically with the clerk, paid filing fees, and obtained the docket number. I then prepared the summons and proof of service, coordinated with a process server, and tracked service confirmation in our case‑management system.

Result

All cases were filed within statutory deadlines, and the firm maintained a 98% on‑time service rate, avoiding dismissals for procedural defaults.

Evaluation Criteria
  • Step‑by‑step clarity
  • Awareness of deadlines and filing fees
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Skipping conflict check or service tracking
Answer Outline
  • Intake and conflict check
  • Draft and review complaint
  • Electronic filing and docketing
  • Prepare summons and proof of service
  • Engage process server and track service
Tip
Include mention of e‑filing portals and docket numbers.
How do you conduct legal research for case law?
Situation

A senior attorney needed precedent for a breach of contract argument.

Task

Locate relevant case law and summarize key holdings.

Action

I started with Westlaw, using Boolean operators and jurisdiction filters. I reviewed headnotes, checked citators for subsequent treatment, and noted any distinguishing facts. I then compiled a memorandum with case citations, brief facts, and relevance to our argument.

Result

The attorney incorporated two strong precedents, strengthening the motion and contributing to a favorable settlement.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What do you do if primary sources are outdated?
  • How do you ensure you’re not missing unpublished opinions?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Effective use of research tools
  • Citation accuracy
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Relying on a single source
Answer Outline
  • Select database and search strategy
  • Apply filters and citators
  • Summarize findings in memo
Tip
Mention checking secondary sources like law review articles for context.

Situational

A client calls upset about a missed filing deadline. How do you respond?
Situation

A client learned that a deadline for a trademark renewal had passed, risking loss of rights.

Task

Address the client’s concerns, assess options, and mitigate damage.

Action

I listened empathetically, apologized for the oversight, and immediately reviewed the docket for any grace period or reinstatement options. I coordinated with the attorney to file a petition for reinstatement with a reasonable cause explanation and kept the client updated throughout the process.

Result

The trademark was reinstated within 30 days, preserving the client’s rights and restoring confidence in our firm.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What documentation supports a reinstatement petition?
  • How do you prevent future missed deadlines?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Empathy, proactive problem‑solving, knowledge of procedural remedies
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Deflecting blame, no action plan
Answer Outline
  • Acknowledge client’s frustration
  • Explain immediate assessment steps
  • Detail remedial actions taken
  • Outcome and client reassurance
Tip
Highlight use of docket alerts or calendar systems to avoid repeats.
You receive a request for documents that may be privileged. What steps do you take?
Situation

During discovery, opposing counsel requested internal emails that could contain attorney‑client privileged communications.

Task

Determine privilege applicability and respond appropriately while complying with discovery rules.

Action

I consulted the supervising attorney, reviewed the email chain for privilege markers, and prepared a privilege log citing the basis for each withheld document. I filed a motion to protect privileged material and communicated the response to opposing counsel, offering to meet and confer if disputes arose.

Result

The court upheld our privilege claim, and the dispute was resolved without sanctions, preserving client confidentiality.

Follow‑up Questions
  • How do you differentiate attorney‑client from work‑product privilege?
  • What if the opposing party challenges the privilege claim?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Understanding of privilege doctrines, procedural compliance
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Unilateral withholding without log
Answer Outline
  • Identify potentially privileged material
  • Consult attorney and create privilege log
  • File appropriate motion and communicate
Tip
Mention the importance of consistent privilege markings in the firm’s document system.
During trial prep, you notice a discrepancy in the evidence list. What is your approach?
Situation

The evidence list omitted a key email chain referenced in the witness outline.

Task

Correct the discrepancy and ensure the evidence list is complete before filing.

Action

I cross‑checked the master file index, located the missing emails, and updated the evidence list with proper citations. I alerted the trial team, secured the original files, and confirmed that the updated list complied with the court’s formatting rules before re‑submitting it.

Result

The corrected evidence list was accepted without objection, and the trial proceeded smoothly with all necessary exhibits available.

Follow‑up Questions
  • What tools do you use to track evidence inventories?
  • How do you handle last‑minute evidence additions?
Evaluation Criteria
  • Detail orientation, systematic verification, communication
Red Flags to Avoid
  • Ignoring the issue, vague explanation
Answer Outline
  • Identify the missing item
  • Locate and verify the document
  • Update evidence list with correct citations
  • Notify team and re‑file
Tip
Reference use of a case‑management spreadsheet or software for tracking exhibits.
ATS Tips
  • legal research
  • document management
  • client communication
  • case management
  • confidentiality
Create a paralegal resume that highlights your legal support skills
Practice Pack
Timed Rounds: 30 minutes
Mix: behavioral, legal knowledge, situational

Ready to ace your paralegal interview? Get personalized coaching now!

Start Coaching

More Interview Guides

Check out Resumly's Free AI Tools